813. Treehouse of Horror XXXVII

Original airdate: October 25, 2026

The premise: In “Bride’s Shed Revisited,” a mysterious backyard shed turns Homer into different men of Springfield every time he goes into it, leaving Marge to choose her ideal new husband. “Dog Boy Afternoon” is a Pet Sematary parody where Homer buries Bart and Santa’s Little Helper in the same grave, and the two come back to life in each other’s bodies. In “Vehicular Dadslaughter,” a teenage Bart and Lisa’s search for their missing father leads them to the DMV, where Patty and Selma trap them alongside Homer: stuck in an endless driver’s ed video where Homer dies again and again due to his careless driving.

The reaction: It was such a wonderful surprise a couple years ago that “Treehouse of Horror XXXIII” was genuinely good, with all three segments being very successful, in my opinion. It proved to me after all these years of ho-hum Halloween specials, greatness was still possible. But if we’re ever gonna get another trilogy of terror at the level of quality, it’s gonna take at least another year, as I found this one to be pretty dull overall. I really don’t know what to make of the first segment: a newlywed Marge is already questioning her decision to marry a big dummy like Homer, but is shocked to find their brand new shed spits out a new husband for her, transforming her home and her life around her. She cycles through a bunch of familiar faces like Lenny, Chief Wiggum and Dr. Hibbert, wanting to find the perfect man for her, eventually landing on guest star Survivor‘s Jeff Probst. But she still misses her Homie, and is shocked to find him in the arms of Lunchlady Dor(a)is, eventually leading her to force them both in the shed to hopefully be together again. I certainly wouldn’t call this spooky enough to be a TOH short, and I also don’t really get what the point is? Marge gets to experience what life would be like with a better husband, but she’s cycling through the other shitty men of Springfield, and the episode isn’t really examining how different her life is or what she wants. They also did a similar short to this in the past where Homer kept dying and coming back in different bodies, which at least is a greater supernatural angle than this is. Segment two isn’t much better, with the mind swap thing of Bart acting like a dog not getting much reaction from me. The special felt incredibly casual up to this point, not really having anything too extreme, at least until we get to the end of this one where a ragingly drunk Homer is about to send Bart-in-SLH’s-body to be put down, and Lisa unleashes a pack of dogs on him, who proceed to bloodily and violently rip out his eyeballs and tear his guts out, maybe the most violent scene in any Treehouse of Horror, but in a way that felt extremely out of left field. Then the ending is Homer and Snowball I are buried and switch bodies and Homer’s eyes and body are intact again. Whatever. Segment three is the best by default, since it at least has a somewhat interesting premise of Homer being trapped in a looping purgatory of being done in by his own bad driving. It feels a little bit old hat in 2026 to be making fun of these 1950s style instructional videos, but after the first two lame stories, I was fine to just roll with this. Patty and Selma as the architects of Homer’s eternal torture certainly feels like an appropriate TOH segment, and this executes that idea as good as it can, I suppose. So yeah, another Halloween in the books. It’s insane that we’re now at well over a hundred individual TOH segments. And yes, we did just get “The Revengening,” but I respect that more for the Apu final act than as a full-length TOH. It’d be nice if we could get another solid TOH before the show finally closes up shop, which I have to assume will be forty years from now. Now that’s scary.

Three items of note:
– The show opening is a tribute to Nightmare Before Christmas with all our favorite Springfieldians recreated as spooky stop-motion denizens of Halloween Town singing a riff on “This is Halloween.” The sequence is incredibly well-realized by the folks at Stooopid Buddy Studios… but I don’t know what else to say about it. There’s no joke to it, no parody, no twist, nothing. Lisa sings that the specials are not canon, and then Flanders as Oogie Boogie bursts with green goo and the title appears. That’s it. It’s an incredibly cute tribute, but I dunno, is it too much to expect the show to do more than this? Like if this were an incredibly well done fan tribute, I would be more fond of it than something made by the show itself.
– I remember a couple years ago in “Treehouse of Horror XXXIV,” the three segments didn’t have title cards at their beginnings. They appeared a couple minutes into each segment themselves, but they were kind of awkwardly placed that they didn’t feel like title cards, it was all very odd. This year’s special does the same thing, but at least the mid-segment title cards are very clear and proper title cards. But why’d they randomly do this again. I dunno, I like when the title is at the start, it lets you know what you’re getting into. It always felt like their EC Comics tribute where you see the pun title on the first page to get you in the mood for the story. These segments are short enough that it’s strange to have a 45-second cold open to your seven minute story.
– Jeff Probst feels like a weird booking, but I have to remind myself that even though Survivor is on its 900th season, the show still gets very good ratings. I also couldn’t help but think that Probst is in his 60s, while this story is about a 20-something Marge falling head over heels for him. But then I figured that this also had to be a younger Probst since this takes place in Homer and Marge’s past. Then I told myself to fucking cut it out, this is a Halloween show, who cares about the stupid timeline. But then Probst makes a joke about Survivor season 42, so this is current day Probst. That season aired in 2022, so this would to be magical future Jeff Probst appearing before a fifteen-ish years younger Marge. Holy fuck am I still talking about this? Goddamn let it go.

13 thoughts on “813. Treehouse of Horror XXXVII”

  1. I really wish the show would not hype things that are the shortest parts of the episode, but that’s marketing for you.

    I agree with you that of the three segments, the third was easily the best; usually it seems every year, the segment that they are the least confident in is always the second, and I can tell as it’s meant to be based off of Pet Semetary… but the plot of that book (and the films) was that it was supposed to be that animals buried in the land would become minions of a wendigo, and besides; they already did the “swap bodies” shtick decades prior.

    Can I say how out of date the writers are for having 1950s 35mm film? I know it’s a common trope to have safety films be shown on old film, but growing up in the 90s and 2000s, we had long switched to VHS and DVD by that point, which just has me wondering how isolated the staff are to modern times. At least the students reacted appropriately to Homer’s various deaths; with thunderous applause.

  2. The second segment was pushed more for the Freaky Friday element rather than the Pet Sementary part. Though I also agree that it’s the worst of the segments (a common theme for Selman’s THoH’s where the second segment is the worst) and suffers the most from the ‘style over substance’ vibe these past few installments have given. Homer’s sudden character shift is too abrupt and seemingly just to justify how gratuitous his death was which wasn’t worth it (both the character shift and the death scene).

  3. In all seriousness, this was slightly better than last year’s even if it still has spades of the ‘style over substance’ vibe of the past few, particularly when it comes to the intro which was too short to justify the hype and the second segment being the most style over substance to a fault.

    As for the other segments though? First one was OK with the only egregious part being Tiffany Haddish’s appearance and the final gag with Rod & Todd being a complete wet fart. Third segment was the best as it had vibes of the earlier THoH segments with the Bart & Lisa duo, except now as teenagers. And it was the segment that had the biggest laughs even if they were only two (Bart & Lisa defeating the biker gang and the final one with Patty & Selma stuck in line).

    Looking forward to the next two episodes where they first try an idea that should’ve never been attempted in any era especially how badly they treated bi-polar and the one after that where they continue to fail to realize that any major Kirk appearance post-Hostile Kirk Place is never going to work.

  4. My thoughts from another website, so it’s going to go over the stories similarly to your post:

    What a total let down after last week’s excellent episode.  I’m not even sure where to begin with this one.  First off, does Maggie even still exist?  I can’t remember her being in a single scene in this episode at all.  Anyway, the opening segment is meant to be a parody of Nightmare Before Christmas, but I’m not exactly sure what the parody is.  They don’t really do anything with it.  It just exists.

    The first story isn’t even a horror story.  Marge has been married to Homer for a year and builds a shed on her own, which somehow alters history to give her another husband.  She is freaked out and disdains Lenny being his replacement even though she doesn’t know anything about him.  Then it comes Wiggum, who is the only one that truly shows why she would hate him and gets him replaced.  She goes through a whole run down as if it’s speed dating, but none of them are any good, all of which is done through telling, not showing.  We never seen WHY they aren’t a good match for her.  Then some random celebrity becomes one of her time shifts and the only reason I know he is a celebrity is because she make sure to say something along the lines of, “You’re <soandso> from that show Survivor Season <whatever>.”  It’s like they needed to explain to the audience who this guy was because that’s his only character trait.  He does nothing, which is exactly how this episode played out.

    The second story was I guess a spoof on Pet Semetary, though I’m not really sure how as I don’t recall the girl and the pet swapping bodies with each other when they’re buried.  Either way, Homer accidentally gets Santa’s Little Helper killed, then Bart, and I thought that is what this story was going to be about, Homer accidentally killing off his loved ones.  That actually would have been fun.  Instead, it’s basically a less funny version of Fly vs Fly with Homer being the biggest asshole imaginable.

    The third story is really the only one that truly feel like it had an idea that made sense with Patty and Selma trapping Homer in a continous string of car accident videos where he dies at the end of each video.  Bart and Lisa get trapped in them with him and have to help him get out.  Again, Maggie is nowhere to be found.  It had some fun moments, but ultimately is as forgettable as the other two stories.

    Overall, this was another lousy year and it seems like Hulu hasn’t posted the Bob’s Burgers Halloween episode to off-set it, which is what I have been using each year to get The Simpsons taste out of my mouth.

    And one again, please for the love of mighty mouse, get rid of these fucking voice actors!!!  They are horrid!!

    1. The dating montage has Marge be picky with the suitors… and rejected Moe instantly. Like, it was one thing to be unhappy with Wiggum as he was slovenly, horribly out of shape, and needy, but Marge hadn’t even the depths of Moe before she punched him.

      It’s one of those things where you probably expected it since one of the most famous Moe jokes was him being so undesirable a date he simply walked straight to the rejects but at least have Moe be lecherous when he steps out of the shed.

    2. “And one again, please for the love of mighty mouse, get rid of these fucking voice actors!!! They are horrid!!”

      I’ll never know how it’s the big 2026 and people still think it’s okay to fire people over something they don’t like (let alone their age).

      1. “I’ll never know how it’s the big 2026 and people still think it’s okay to fire people over something they don’t like (let alone their age).”

        Does it matter? When people are unfit to do the job they’re hired for you get rid of them. The voice actors, especially Harry and Julie, are unfit to continue voicing their characters. They have more than enough money from their 35+ years of service, they can afford to life in retirement.

        They are supposed to be voice actors NOT the geriatric department. When there are VAs who could do the job better they should be replaced so new blood can have a chance.

      2. How do you know they’re “unfit to do their job”? Cuz they’re old now? That comes off as ageist (especially “geriatric department”). It like actors who reach old age and start sound old, no matter good and capable they still are at the job they were given, shouldn’t get to do it anymore (I’m not saying you are saying that, but it still makes it feel like that). If the old voice actors literally couldn’t act anymore, it would be a different story, but apart from Mr. Burns, they clearly can.
        Julie may be hard to listen to, but that’s cuz she’s been using a tone closer to her own to put less strain on her voice. Plus, she can still do all of what’s needed very well (notably the crying scenes). She would’ve retired or been forced to leave by if she couldn’t do her job at all now.
        I’ll admit, Harry’s Mr. Burns voice is pretty bad, but that’s it from what I’ve seen. All of his other ones either just sound older (Flanders) or the exact same (which is the case for all of the other old actors too). You can’t just get rid of perfectly capable actors just because they got old when it doesn’t even affect their capabilities or episode quality (7 Beer Itch being the exception). If they can do good their jobs, it shouldn’t matter if their “too old.”

    3. Only the most recent pet sematary killed Ellie. In the book and first film her baby brother Gage died instead. It is underwhelming because zombie Gage is supposed to be threatening but he’s just a toddler with a knife. Child’s Play does more to make Chucky interesting and scary.

    4. With all the respect in the world, Kaiju, Jaden is absolutely right here.

      If your problem with Harry, Julie etc. really is *that* great… may I make a few suggestions?

      (1) Take up the matter with Harry, Julie etc. themselves. (2) Take it up with the Mouse himself. (3) Keep it to X, the ‘Book, and other such platforms. (4) Don’t force others to agree with you; that’s not how it works and that’s not how it’s supposed to work.

      And don’t forget that even after all these years, Harry, Julie etc. might actually still *enjoy* what they’re doing? Yes, they *could* retire on the millions they’ve made – but perhaps they don’t *want* to? Perhaps they’ve come to enjoy what they do so much that they want to go on until either they drop or the plug is finally pulled? Money doesn’t matter all that much to them now, nor do ratings – and nor does criticism?

      (All this said, it’s quite the thought that Julie has been voicing Marge for half her life now – and Dan, Nancy, Yeardley and Hank have all been involved with the show for *more* than half of their respective lives.)

  5. Hm, I haven’t gotten around to The Revengening yet, but this is a different episode. I’m sure I can read this review without that neat twist Mike alluded to getting spoiled.

    …

    …

    …

    …

    …

Leave a Reply