6. Moaning Lisa

(originally aired February 11, 1990)
I feel Lisa Simpson is one of the more under-appreciated character in all of television. Within the show she certainly is, unfortunately stuck as the misunderstood middle child of the Simpson clan. Amidst her dopey father, trouble-making brother, and her mother desperately holding the family together, Lisa’s incredible creative and intellectual gifts are mostly gone unnoticed. But outside the show she is also the target of scorn. While later years have dabbled in making her the smugly smart guy or political mouthpiece, Lisa was never really a fan favorite against the more popular Bart or Homer. But she plays a very important role in the series, she’s earnest, she works hard, but in the end she can never quite catch a break. In many ways, she’s the most human character out of anyone on the show, and the episodes focused on her always tend to be the most emotional and down-to-earth, and this very first one is no exception.

The set-up is that Lisa feels sad. It’s not so much a sadness as a general malaise about her station in life; undermined by any creative outbursts at school and generally unacknowledged at home, she has basically ostracized herself from a world she believes holds no happiness for her. It’s an emotional arc that I can’t think of any other show tackling, and it never holds back. You really feel for Lisa and her unfortunate state of mind because we’ve all felt this sense of unhappiness sometime in our lives. While they are not the most attentive at times, her parents express concern. Homer, while not having the slightest idea of her daughter’s problems, does his best to hear her out and cheer her up, but to no avail. It’s a really sweet moment between the two, with Lisa acknowledging her father’s best intentions.

Lisa eventually finds some sort of refuge in a mysterious wandering jazz man named Bleeding Gums Murphy, resulting in an impromptu jam session late at night on the downtown bridge (I believe the same one Homer nearly jumped off of three episodes ago). Murphy is a pretty famous Simpsons character, though he’s only really been in two episodes (and the opening every week). He’s helpful to Lisa, but also can be a little backhanded. (“You know, you play pretty well for someone with no real problems!”) But, Lisa earned recognition from a kindred spirit, and an outlet for her frustrations, but it is by no means a solution to her problem. There’s a happy ending here, but nothing permanent like out of a typical sitcom.

I guess the side plot should be mentioned, featuring Homer’s efforts to beat Bart at a boxing video game. I guess since the main story was so dour and serious this runner served as a comedic outlet and break from the drama. It’s got a lot of great funny bits in it, continuing with the season 1 tradition of Homer trying to impress his son and prove himself a man, but also features some early Homer overreaction, like his crazy dream sequence, and his equally crazy breakdown after Marge unplugs the television right before he finally bests his son. Seeing a grown man cry over a video game is probably the first truly pathetic act we’ve seen from Homer, but certainly not the last.

Marge, meanwhile, thinks back to her mother’s advice to her as a child, to mask your emotions and remain smiling to fit into the group. Her advice about bottling up your emotions seems very true to her character, especially when you figure how much she puts up with from her family in the years to come. The scene where she vests Lisa with this advice is so great, it’s such poor advice, but Marge means it with such earnestly, believing this will make her daughter happy. The end result of witnessing Lisa about to be take advantage of and undermined because of it prompts Marge to backtrack, telling Lisa to just be herself. It’s a wonderful turn, and a sweet ending.

Tidbits and Quotes
– In the opening, we’ve seen Mr. Largo throw Lisa out of class for her jazzy outbursts during class, but here we finally see him in the show itself, where we see he’s basically what we expected. His very name gives it away, largo a term for a slow and broad musical tempo, completely uncreative and unambitious. When Lisa describes her music reflects those hardworking Americans who go unnoticed and unappreciated, Largo responds, “Well, that’s all fine and good, but none of those unpleasant people are going to be at the recital next week.”
– The boxing game “Super Slugfest” is a great Simpsons-esque parody of video games, with its old-school graphics and Punch-Out style meshed with over-the-top graphic violence, like a final blow decapitation, and the winner dancing on the loser’s grave in the ring, complete with triumphant low-bit music.
– Lisa, an eight-year-old girl, walks out late at night and receives advice from an elderly stranger. All of this should point to this being super sketchy, but it doesn’t really feel that way at all. Well… maybe a little, but Murphy seems sincere enough. Mostly.
– We get the first appearance of a Simpsons staple: someone waking up, sitting up in bed screaming. Also a really big, long Homer scream. And funny.
– “You know Marge, getting old is a terrible thing. I think the saddest day of my life was when I realized I could beat my Dad at most things, and Bart experienced that at the age of four.”
– I’ve always loved Murphy’s explanation of his name, in that he never goes to the dentist. “I suppose I should go to one, but I’ve got enough pain in my life as it is.”
– One last bit, I also love how Lisa plays a baritone saxophone, one that’s almost as big as she is. It’s a perfect visual metaphor on how she’s a big fish in a small pond, a girl who hold greater aspirations than others around her. It’s also just a funny gag when you see her really playing and struggling to physically keep up with her emotional music.

10 thoughts on “6. Moaning Lisa

  1. I used to not like this one very much, mainly due to it being low on humor aside from the Bart/Homer subplot. Lately, though, it’s sort of grown on me. I think we can all relate to Lisa; that is, sometimes feeling melancholic for no obvious reason. One scene that particularly resonates with me in recent years is when Marge tells Lisa to fake being happy so people will like her better. While said with good intentions, what Marge gives Lisa is actually really bad advice, because by repressing her feelings deep inside, they can be unleashed later in undesirable ways, or cause her to develop a complex. If we’re not honest with ourselves and others, it’s unhealthy. That comment is also multi-layered, because she obviously has to repress a lot, being married to Homer and all.

    Thankfully, Marge redeemed herself when she saw how Lisa’s fake happiness caused her to be taken advantage of immediately (“You can do my math homework!”). When Marge apologizes and says she can stop smiling and Lisa responds, “I -feel- like smiling.” with a sincere smile, it’s an acknowledgement that she knows Marge cares about her true feelings. It’s a sweet moment.

    There are other season 1 episodes I like more (“Krusty Gets Busted” is probably the best), but like I said, this one gets better as I get older.

  2. I love Homer’s scream as Bart clearly punches his head off or smashes his face in in some nasty way.

    Reminds me of how Homer was ‘screaming through the adverts’ when he thought Apu was gonna kill him. And I’m pretty sure that was the first scream Homer had done.

    Great underlooked episode with such great moments and lines. Get away from that jazz man is pretty funny. Just a shame a lot of people think to ones like Bart the General when thinking of their faves. Like Life in the Fast Lane, this pulls off a great mix of sad and happy.

  3. You left out my favorite line from Murphy. “Jazz isn’t about making you feel better, it’s about making other people feel worse! And making some money on the side.”

    It may be lost on people today just how over-the-top the violence in the boxing game was for the time. Remember that Mortal Kombat wouldn’t be released for another three years.

  4. I really agree with you about Lisa being an under-appreciated character. She was one of the first characters on TV who resonated with me. While I was an only child, I didn’t connect with her in terms of familial relations, but I understood her in how she felt so disconnected from her peers in terms of intellect, maturity, creativity, and conscientiousness. I somehow got her character even though I was only five when I first saw this episode. (I remember how huge of a deal it was for grade schoolers to be allowed to watch The Simpsons–I was one of the lucky ones. And I suppose my comprehension was a testament of the writers’ ability of accessing multiple age groups and levels of intelligence.) While I would never claim that Lisa is perfect, I find the bitching about Lisa to be ironic considering that the show has often displayed and ridiculed the callousness and short-sightedness of their behavior.

  5. This is one of my top5 episode. No other tv show could have been so deep and complete like The Simpsons showed to be in this episode. A masterpiece.

  6. This episode is wonderful and one of the best Lisa episodes ever, if not the best. She truly feels legitimate here. Of course, what the hell is an 8 year old girl doing outside in the middle of the night talking to some stranger that could have been a bad man?

  7. These season 1 episodes hold up fairly well on rewatch. I never liked the earlier seasons much when I was younger and this is an episode I never cared for as well but both have grown on me over time.

    Marge and her advice to Lisa at the end was a powerful scene and Lisa’s arc in this episode was very well done and engaging. Enjoyed the subplot with Bart and Homer as well.

  8. Plus there’s the funny part where Homer goes to the arcade, trying to act discreet even though the quarter dispenser man (?) isn’t buying it for a second. Also, love the random cool kid who wears sunglasses indoors and teaches Homer the tricks of the game in exchange for Homer barking like a dog. The scene also makes me miss arcades in general; that particular social aspect of gaming is long gone.

  9. Another great episode. I’m strangely fond of the slightly more serious in tone first season, and this episode exemplifies it really well, with the somewhat dower tone due to Lisa’s feelings, while also not forgetting about jokes like with Bart’s subplot with Homer. A very strong episode all around.

  10. In my opinion, I can certainly call this a fantastic episode, everything about this episode is done so flawlessly. Both Lisa and Marge are amazing here (enjoy them while you can because a lot of Lisa and Marge episodes are appalling). Marge’s advice (while terrible) makes sense for her character because when Marge went through the same thing, she was told by her mother to be happy at all times. Lisa takes that advice and almost gets taken advantage of.

    I really love the message, saying that with depression, there isn’t always an easy way out for it and some people just care about making themselves look helpful rather than actually being helpful. Easily top tier episode.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s